Skip to main content

Politics & Family Dynamics: Keeping It Together

Politics & Family Dynamics: Keeping It Together

"We can disagree and still love each other unless your disagreement is rooted in my oppression and denial of my humanity and right to exist."
– James Baldwin, American Writer & Essayist

Some of us in Oswego, Aurora, Plainfield and Naperville (IL) may have found ourselves in a moment like this during the last few years:

We're at a family gathering. Someone makes a remark or opinion about society or politics. Among the group, it instantly opens shaken cans of feelings and views ready to spray and fizz at everyone in earshot.

In other words, a parent, sibling or relative makes it clear they know what's really going on out there. Perhaps we believe we think or know better. In some cases, maybe we're right. In others, maybe we're mistaken.

And in the end, does it matter? Truth in politics is an evasive concept. We often chase it with a resolute will that can lose much with little to gain, especially among those we care about.

The Evolution of Political Polarization

Political disagreement has always been with us. Today, our awareness of it is much greater with powerfully present media and technology that amplify it with unrestricted frequency.

At the same time, boundaries of respect and decorum are being pushed and moved in ways they never have. So how did we get here?

Those of a certain age can remember the upheaval of the late 1960s and early 70s, when society became polarized over matters such as civil rights, women's rights, Vietnam, Watergate and the assassinations of figures such as JFK, RFK and MLK.

Some can argue that this was when trust in government began its steady slope toward where we find ourselves today. Along the way, other factors emerged to help grease the skids of decline.

In the 1990s, polarization thickened with the rise of partisan talk radio, the 24-hour news cycle and increasingly toxic campaign strategies. Reaching beyond policy stances, partisanship also began to represent our lifestyles and identities.

In the 2000s, early social media and online communities injected extra emotional charge into matters of politics as well as national identity and security.

After 2010, polarization made its defining and most divisive leap with the colossal expansion and influence of social-media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter and YouTube.

Closely tracking our preferences and tendencies, the apps then led us into algorithm-driven echo chambers that isolated us from the fair and even exchange of thoughts and ideas.

Fueled by misinformation and "rage-baiting," such sequestering allowed people to become more obstinate and isolated on matters such as immigration, marriage, sexual orientation, guns and the economy.

Now a leading predictor of social relationships, political identity shaped further by biased news and influencers had bored in to narrow our perspectives. It carried state and federal conflicts deeper into communities, the workplace and, ultimately, the family.

Partisan Disagreement in the Home

Social psychologists have long understood that simply identifying with a group from a differing or competitive viewpoint can lead people to form "tribes" and perceive "outsiders" with greater suspicion, doubt and mistrust.

Before the current era, the dividing lines among identifying groups were often based on factors such as race, religion, ethnicity, age and gender. Today, political affiliation is the predominant cause of seeing others as us versus them.

Our politics are now even more about personal identification and morals than they are about policy and interpretations of governing factors. Those who belong to or identify with a group can feel justified in speaking of the other with contempt and treating them with disdain or even hostility.

Because political views link to a moral identity, they can reach far into a family in Oswego, Aurora, Plainfield or Naperville. Disagreements can feel more charged and threatening. We might find it more difficult to "agree to disagree." Differences are not just matters of opinion, but also of character.

The dividing lines can cause families to separate both physically and mentally. Members might move to areas that better align with their views. Being "left" or "right" might influence whom they will date and marry or whom they'll welcome to the family.

Research has indicated that family estrangement because of politics has been rising in the U.S. A survey by The Harris Poll found that one in two adults was estranged from a close relative. Of those adults, one in five cited political differences as the reason.

One-third of American adults also reported feeling uncomfortable at a family gathering in the past year because of a relative's political views. One-third further expressed a concern that political disagreements could cast a shadow over future family events.

Reducing Political Stress in the Family

It's important to note that not all viewpoints that vary have negative impacts on families.

Some families might find themselves engaging conversations about thoughts and values even more. Disagreements can motivate a family to see what's human in the other members even more clearly as well, inspiring love and compassion. Parents also might use political events and issues as opportunities to teach critical thinking to their children.

As much as media and technology may fan the flames of political division and outrage, families can still effectively cope and stay balanced. The following are a few guidelines that can encourage peace and respect where beliefs and views might differ.

Define boundaries of political talk. It can be easy to forget or overlook this step for conflict avoidance. Communicate with family members about when political discussions are proper and when they are not. If a member starts to cross that line, kindly and simply remind them of the boundary that exists to benefit all members.

If someone says "let's not talk about this," respect that wish. We can also help prevent flare-ups by not veering into politics during stressful, uncomfortable moments such as during family dinners or holiday gatherings. If a conversation erupts unexpectedly, we can choose to not react and to speak calmly in the right moment.

Focus on values. Many political disagreements come from a deeper place that holds our heartfelt views and feelings about issues such as fairness, freedom, justice and empathy.

People on the "left and "right" may not always realize that they share values although with different outer variables – e.g. approaches to supporting the rule of law.

Rather than confront a family member with "how can you believe that?" we can seek to understand why an expressed value is important. In addition to showing patience and empathy, we make others feel respected when we make them feel heard.

We also might find out the value is much like our own. This further can remind us that the relationship matters much more than proving a point or winning an argument.

Limit exposure to social media and news. The tech and media companies were not designed to be our friends. Much profit is built by prolonging our time with their content and screens.

At the same time, expressed outrage in content can make us addicted to it by releasing dopamine in the brain. This can keep us returning for more even when we've had enough.

We can contribute to mental health and family dynamics by setting time limits on our screens. We can avoid doomscrolling before and during family time. We can be mindful and take a break when we sense our stress or anxiety rising because of political content. This can help lower tension and stress in the household.

Forgo mind conversions and zero-sum engagements. A big part of political discord in a family can hinge on the feeling that someone is trying to prove someone wrong. If a discussion has a perceived winner and loser, relational fractures will widen.

Plus, in a zero-sum win-lose discussion, we will almost never change anyone's mind nor let ours be changed.

We rather can seek to understand the heart of what our family member is saying and relate it to its higher aim, such as a sincere love for country. This can reduce defensiveness and show our respect.

Some of us may have family members who can be more combative and rigid than others. For those individuals, we can look to lower tension and establish connection by steering the focus toward shared non-political ground, such as a common liking for movies, musicians, sports teams or hobbies (e.g. fishing, painting, hiking).

Family Therapy: Contact Us Today

Empowered Life Therapy believes in living as the authentic self with clarity, balance and strength among others. If you struggle with a family stressor such as political tension and you'd like to discuss how to restore a sense of peace, we welcome you.

Simply contact us at (630) 383-9999 to discuss our support for families from Oswego, Aurora, Plainfield and Naperville (IL).

We're here to help!
We're a no-judgment zone, so feel free to come to us with any questions or concerns.